Make us your homepage

in

The Tennis Channel

The Tennis Channel Community Message Boards

Tennis Commentator's Best & Worst List........

Last post 07-28-2008 11:05 PM by Malcolm. 0 replies.
Page 1 of 1 (1 items)
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 07-28-2008 11:05 PM

    Tennis Commentator's Best & Worst List........

     

    List of Commentators some may be unfamiliar with.

    ATP Master Series TV European Commentators (out if 5 STARS) *****

    Robbie Koenig **** 4 Stars     GREAT

    South African Commentator, very good analyst keeps the focus on tennis and the game skills.  Medium talker usually lets you enjoy the points.  And often a delight to hear his voice...


    To see photo click here

    Jason Goodall **** 4 Stars        GOOD


    Usually OK but can get a little negative. But for the most part I think his commentary is appreciated and well done the majority of the time.. BTW Jason HAS the BEST voice of all the commentators and he knows when to stop talking.  I would call him more of a leader when it comes to the European tennis commentating.


    Darren Cahill ***** 5 Stars    PERFECT

    Australian Commentator, Darren is the best ALWAYS positive, I have heard Doug try to bait him into negative commentary and he never bites.. He enjoys tennis and it is obvious through his very professional descriptions of the sport.  Sometimes Darren is on the sidelines reporting.  Darren has true passion for the tennis. He cares about the future of the sport.


    To see Darren click here


    Doug Adler ** 2 Stars            AWFUL


    Doug NO doubt knows tennis.  That's not his problem.  His issues lie within the constant personal attacks against various players when commentating.  HE HATES Roger Federer and will pounce whenever Fed is having a bad game.  HE HATES Safin and I can go on and on about how he rarely has ANYTHING positive to say when players are not at their best...  Its depressing to hear this, I think Doug is very smart but the most tennis fans review him as a bitter jerk.  DOUG only likes you if you play PERFECT tennis....  very unfortunate.


    American Commentators

    Patrick McEnroe ***** 5 Stars     PERFECT

    Extremely professional, nothing like his brother the best of all American tennis commentators.  Tennis would be lost without Patrick compared to his fellow commentators.  His often mangled and unkept hair is a whole different topic.

    To see Pat click here

    Mary Joe Fernandez *** 3 Stars        Good

    Mary Joe gets the job done often positive but can get kinda flat and homey looking. Not anywhere as negative as the others, usually she is better at breaking down the game because of her success as a player.

    See Mary Joe here

    Mary Carrillo **** 4 Starts     Good

    Mary is Hard Core, she tells it like it is, but with respect.  She says the truths that most commentators wont.  Not degrading the player but bluntly identifying the reasons they struggle.  I think Serena Williams motivation for winning her last Aussie open few years back came because she was tired of  the relentless mouth of Mary Carrillo and others talking about how out of shape and unfit she was.

    Click here to see Carrillo

    John McEnroe *** 3 Stars     Average

    John is way too busy flapping his gums about his own tennis career. Surprisingly not as negatived as others, but he never stops talking, worships Nadal too much, and continually wanting to play every player he's commentating about.  This man just cant focus on anything other than himself playing or challenging every other tennis player currently on tour.  Its annoying and predictable.

    Jonnie MC

    Martina Navratilova      NO STARS

    The worst of them all is Martina Navratilova, she talks more about herself and when she played than anyone else (even more than John MC), and she sometimes curses like a sailor on National TV, I'm surprised she hasn't already been released. I didn't think there was anyone who displays more bitterness than Doug Adler, but Martina takes all the cakes. New career please.. One where she can speak inappropriately as she wishes.

    Great player but she gotta go...


    See Martina

    Cliff Drysdale  ** 2 stars  Average

    Sorry Cliff but its time to retire. Cliff who can be charming with his voice and distinguished with his looks needs to hang up his mic.  If i hear one more life story about a player, when the player is playing I'm gonna band tennis.  This man NEVER SHUTS UP.  Stepping on his co-commentators all the time telling some over the top exaggerated childhood story for the 100th time.  PLEASE retire Cliffy.... We love you though....

    See Ciffy here

    Jimmy Arias  ** 2 stars  Average

    I like Jimmy, he favors certain players. That's obvious. but overall i think is average because of his lack of commentating experience. He's another who comes across like he would rather put the Mic down and go out and play.  It seems as if he doesn't take commentating as serious as others.  For him its kinda something to do while not playing on champions tour.

    See Jimmy Here


    Leif Shiras ***** 5 Stars

    Where do I begin, I love Leif. ALWAYS positive, great attitude and great voice. I think every one can take a page from his book.  Not asknowledgeable as a atp master series commentator but he makes up for it with is easy and fun going spirit.  Just a joy to hear.

    See Leif

    THE WORST OF ALL TIME     THE HUMAN BABBLER   NO STARS  

    DI CK ENBERG
    I was watching a match on NBC when Di ck Enberg started to describe how sexy Maria Sharapova was. Talking about here legs and another time when he was referencing the boobs of another female tennis player.  At his age this behavior is disturbing, I think enough can be said by putting him in the Justin Gimelstob category. Disgusting...  yuck!!

    See Enberg
Page 1 of 1 (1 items)
Powered by Community Server (Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems